“The only thing a golfer needs is more daylight” – Ben Hogan
Mark Twain once mentioned October as a peculiarly dangerous month to speculate in stocks. He wasn’t the most successful investor and actually spent his later years traveling the globe paying off debts he owed despite his book royalties and wife’s inheritance. He spent more than he made, like so many people today. Mr. Twain went on to mention the other dangerous months to invest his money of November, December, January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August and September.
As bad as things seemed leading into the mid-terms, it’s worth noting the S&P 500 historical 4Q performance going back to 1950. November and December have historically been good months, with average returns of 4.1 percent in Q4. We see that when Q3 returned 7 percent or greater (14 out of 14 observations) the average Q4 return has been 5.9 percent. Note: we saw 7.2 percent in 2018 for those three months.
Finally, as illustrated above, there is a 7.8 percent average return in mid-term election years during the last fiscal quarter. The S&P 500 has not declined in the 12 months following a mid-term election since 1946. I’m not saying there can’t be a first, but pointing out a fun fact. We’ll have to see what happens by November ’19. In the meantime we should keep a level head with our investments and avoid any kind of irrational behavior just because the markets are volatile.
The Wall of Worry has been plentiful since the beginning of the year. Some of the issues on this wall are: anything Trump related, tax cuts for the rich, foreign policy rifts, yield curve flattening, inflation, correction/recession, re-negotiations of global trade agreements, Brexit/Grexit/Ital-leave, late stage Bull Market coming to an end, the confirmation of a Supreme Court Justice, high oil prices and then low oil prices, etc. The wall of worry.
Two points about the continuous wall of worry. First, we are comforted that it exists and even more that it is being studied in respectful fashion. The time to really worry is when there is no wall of worry. Remember when the .com era was spitting out companies right and left and people were quitting their day job to cash in on day trading. No wall of worry. Or, how about in 2008 when Citigroup’s CEO, Chuck Prince, commented about originating and selling mortgages on the cusp of the housing crisis. The ladies locker room employee used to come to the golf shop and fill me in on how easy it was to get loan after loan on rental properties she would never be able to pay off simply by showing the bank some equity existed since last month. What a racket.
Secondly, we do not see any of these current worry items spilling over into the fundamental economic or earnings data at present. Neither do we see them leaking into the confidence readings of key constituents in the economic and business world. Confidence on the part of consumers, CEO’s, small business owners and employees appear to remain robust.
Enough about the wall of worry. We want to switch gears for a moment and suggest items we consider to be on a wall of opportunity. These items are fairly high probability of occurring by the way. Nonetheless, they don’t seem to be on most investors’ radar. Any one or a combination of these items could lift earnings and hence the market. These include:
- Rising business investment that leads to rising labor productivity and a virtuous cycle of rising demand
- Innovation via 5G (have you seen Verizon stock lately?), cloud, AI, machine learning
- 3-d printers and apps for tablets around the country contribute to efficiencies not shown in the output data…but its there
- The threat of tariff’s by the United States result in a trade agreements that lowers global tariffs (how could imports plus exports be rising if we had a trade war now?) Forget about the talking points of a trade deficit being bad
- The Fed avoids a policy error and looks at the data rather than auto pilot rate hikes
- GDP sticking around above 3% longer than expected
- Energy exports around the globe without the threat of pricing controls from OPEC
- All unemployment continues to fall and the poor are becoming richer
We see evidence of rising capital expenditures that are long overdue (chart above). This is the result of the strong confidence readings by CEO’s and small business owners planning with their capital, tax incentives to invest, and the estimated $700 billion in repatriation of foreign profits by U.S. companies. This is significant. It can drive productivity by workers and allow companies to increase wages without raising prices on their customers excessively and maintain profits…..a phenomenon that generates a virtuous cycle of rising demand and profits.
We remain positive because of the solid data, not the season and not how far up we can get on the wall of worry. The leading economic indicators continue to climb, unemployment is low, wages are rising, GDP is sustained in spite of two terrible hurricanes last quarter, core inflation remains low, business investment is picking up and earnings and revenue growth are robust. Total trade (exports plus imports) is growing which means there is not a trade war right now. We’ll continue to study and see if the worry items begin to impact fundamentals and get the upper hand in a negative way. In contrarian fashion, we like the landscape for equities and would be obliged to help with all matters financial in your life. We look back at this calendar year and need to ask ourselves a final question, “have I made my absolute best effort in saving this calendar year by investing in MY future?”
Blake Parrish, CFP®
Senior VP, Portfolio Manager
Phone: (503) 619-7237
E-mail: blake@bpfinancialassoc.com
Certified Financial Planner Boardof Standards Inc. owns the certification marks CFP®, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, CFP® (with plaque design) and CFP® (with flame design) in the U.S., which it awards to individuals who successfully complete CFP Board’s initial and ongoing certification requirements.”